I'm putting this in here instead of in Off Topic as I want only the people who really know about TWG to vote. And there's still people in Off Topic who don't know anything about TWG for now. Anyway, here's the canidates for hosting TWG V.

Bold your vote.

TheMuffinMan
Players: 18 slots
Wolves: 4
Game Type: Standard TWG Game

Renegade
Players: 18-20 slots
Wolves: 4
Game Type: Standard TWG Game

Mantrid
Players: 20 slots
Wolves: 4
Game Type: I'd like to drop the Guardian, and then have 3 Masons. Masons
are humans, and they know all the other Masons. An instant network,
but one that may look like wolves to other players, as there is no
real way to confirm that they're Masons

----------------------------------------------------------------------

I would apply to host myself but I have a feeling my time is going to be rather limited with school in the next while.

Also one added addition to the rules. No showing screenshot's of your PM's. Only copy-pasting text. This is mainly due to the fact that someone with photoshop experience may have an unfair advantage over those who don't, and could make their proof seem more solid this way.

Also, sorry it's late. I thought I said 5:30 EST.

EDIT: 24 hours should be long enough to vote. If we need more it'll extend.

TheMuffinMan. I was hoping for a little more creativity in terms of special roles here... Muffins game is the only one that looks fairly balanced between humans and wolfs to me, and renegade has hosted before. (which is not a bad thing, I loved that game, but other people should get a chance too)

I'm going to vote for Mantrid. I like the idea of having new roles. I also think it will be fairly balanced, since anyone that reveals themself as being important is guaranteed to be killed without a guardian.

I say we give TheMuffinMan a chance. Renegade has already hosted once, and Mantrid's game seems like a guaranteed human win.

I'm going with Renegade because Mantrid's idea seems unbalanced, Renegade has experience (and he would die instantly if he were a player because of his experience anyway) and I just don't like the whole "Fish" thing.

TheMuffinMan - 2 (lolfighter, swiftspear)
Mantrid - 1 (im lost)
Renegade - 1 (Pulse)

TheMuffinMan is clearly the last wolf. My reasons are the sucpicious way he has been acting and his realitive inactivity compared to last game.

Er...
I like his idea because it gives the wolves the most chance, and they need to win sometime...

TheMuffinMan
I'm sorry, the Mason thing sounds like an excellent idea, but it just sounds too overpowering with only 20 people. And Renegade's already hosted, and if we give him another powertrip he'll likely overdose.

Hmm. I like the idea of the masons, but maybe there ought to be an extra wolf to compensate? Or is that tipping the scales too much in the wolves' favour?

I vote for Snidely to change his avatar back, since his old one was so much better.

I'd say Muffin Man. Humies don't need any help.

Renegade. Meh I kind of wanted a wizard (finds out who seers is but doesn't know who wolves are, also works with wolves) to be in one of the games. I mean it opens up lots of things like pretending to be a wizard to trick the wolves or wolves + wizard working together to take down humans.

Also I am not sure about Masons.

TheMuffinMan - 5 (lolfighter, Swiftspear, Isamil, Sky, BadKarma)
Mantrid - 1 (im lost)
Renegade - 2 (Pulse, Petco)

MuffinMan, Since hes got a cool name and i like him

I'm voting for Renegade. He's got experience and TWG3 was cool and um.. yeah.

We need a game that gives more power to the wolves. They obviously need it, since the humans are too good.

Having followed the last 3 twg's with great interest, and wanting to play in this one, i'd have to say that i would prefer a Standard game for my first one. But with the number of people looking to play wouldn't maybe 20 players with 5 wolves be a better option? If anyone goes for that option i will vote for them. Until then i won't cast a random vote, it looks too wolfish. (oh btw when is end of day, i don't want a phantom vote after all!!!)

The failure to kill the Seer (until late game) has been a great downfall of the wolves so far.

I have an idea that would give the wolves somewhat of an advantage depending on how they use it.
The wolves know who was seered. Or if that might be a bit overpowering, the wolves know who gets seered if it's a wolf that's seered.

Comments?

If the wolves were told who was seered, they would have a massive advantage as they could effectively stop the seer from ever networking with confirmed humans. The second idea seems fairly harmless though, and it would probably help the wolves prepare themselves for a public announcement from the seer should he find any wolves.

TheMuffinMan - 6 (lolfighter, Swiftspear, Isamil, Sky, BadKarma, Kerotan)
Mantrid - 1 (im lost)
Renegade - 3 (Pulse, Petco, brute_force)

TheMuffinMan wins! Welcome the new host of TWG V!

Muffin, I'll need to speak with you on IRC privatly.

Go Muffinman, Go Muffinman!

I've never written a story with diolouge before but I guess I could try hosting TWG VI.

And about only knowing who is seered when a wolf gets seered? Can help them prepare, and it can help them figure out who the seer is. The seer is always what wins the game, that would nerf it a bit.

edit: stupid me

voting is alreay over UnderDOG. TheMuffinMan won.

lol I should read more of thread before posting shouldnt I